Mai-HiME Manga: "WHAT IF"s?!
+8
SpiralDasher
Bluholic711
hildebrant
GAP
SpiderNeKoHiME
Luu Sky Sapphire
Highman
The Fire Stirring Ruby
12 posters
Page 1 of 3
Page 1 of 3 • 1, 2, 3
Mai-HiME Manga: "WHAT IF"s?!
As we all know, the My-HiME manga was turned down by almost all fans because of its different storyline, and some scenes that are truly missing in action. Feel free to post your "what if" to the manga, and we'll start discussing it here in this thread. IF you have another, just keep on posting to keep this thread going.
I'll give the first discussion:
What if Mai was secretly influenced by the OL, Takumi? Would she have killed Yuuichi and Natsuki during their confrontation?
((NOTE: I like to experiment at mangas like if it had alternate endings...))
I'll give the first discussion:
What if Mai was secretly influenced by the OL, Takumi? Would she have killed Yuuichi and Natsuki during their confrontation?
((NOTE: I like to experiment at mangas like if it had alternate endings...))
The Fire Stirring Ruby- Ramen Noodles Specialist
- Posts : 1669
Bubuzuke points : 2486
Armitage GUTS!!! : 746
Join date : 2010-12-19
Age : 27
Location : Upstate Sass City
Re: Mai-HiME Manga: "WHAT IF"s?!
The Fire Stirring Ruby wrote:As we all know, the My-HiME manga was turned down by almost all fans because of its different storyline, and some scenes that are truly missing in action. Feel free to post your "what if" to the manga, and we'll start discussing it here in this thread. IF you have another, just keep on posting to keep this thread going.
I'll give the first discussion:
What if Mai was secretly influenced by the OL, Takumi? Would she have killed Yuuichi and Natsuki during their confrontation?
((NOTE: I like to experiment at mangas like if it had alternate endings...))
Yeah she would do it eventually. Kill Tate, bang-bang on Natsuki and make Mikoto her right hand maiden. Mai is a emotional girl and sometimes someone will get advantage of her. Doubtful she would do it.
Highman- Valkyrie
- Posts : 479
Bubuzuke points : 634
Armitage GUTS!!! : 113
Join date : 2010-09-12
Re: Mai-HiME Manga: "WHAT IF"s?!
Manga Mai Tokiha had enough raw power to annihilate a large chunk of the Mai-HiME roster. So, yeah, she could and would if the circumstances were altered.
Great topic, btw! :) Here's a quickie one:
Obsidian Takumi (Easily the superior OL) vs. All twelve HiME from the animeverse. Who would win?
Great topic, btw! :) Here's a quickie one:
Obsidian Takumi (Easily the superior OL) vs. All twelve HiME from the animeverse. Who would win?
Re: Mai-HiME Manga: "WHAT IF"s?!
Luu Sky Sapphire wrote:Great topic, btw! :) Here's a quickie one:
Obsidian Takumi (Easily the superior OL) vs. All twelve HiME from the animeverse. Who would win?
If Kagutsuchi became the Sword of Kagutsuchi, definitely the 12 HiMEs would win... But if not, it would be the OL Takumi's child that would crush the 12 HiMEs altogether. :(
New topic!
What if there was ShizNat PLUS the love triangle between Yuuichi, Mai and Natsuki, would the whole story be changed?
The Fire Stirring Ruby- Ramen Noodles Specialist
- Posts : 1669
Bubuzuke points : 2486
Armitage GUTS!!! : 746
Join date : 2010-12-19
Age : 27
Location : Upstate Sass City
Re: Mai-HiME Manga: "WHAT IF"s?!
The Fire Stirring Ruby wrote:Luu Sky Sapphire wrote:Great topic, btw! :) Here's a quickie one:
Obsidian Takumi (Easily the superior OL) vs. All twelve HiME from the animeverse. Who would win?
If Kagutsuchi became the Sword of Kagutsuchi, definitely the 12 HiMEs would win... But if not, it would be the OL Takumi's child that would crush the 12 HiMEs altogether. :(
New topic!
What if there was ShizNat PLUS the love triangle between Yuuichi, Mai and Natsuki, would the whole story be changed?
OL couldn't do jack squat he's really a couch potato but what If Shizuru like men the whole time and had fling with Yuuichi instead of Reito.
Highman- Valkyrie
- Posts : 479
Bubuzuke points : 634
Armitage GUTS!!! : 113
Join date : 2010-09-12
Re: Mai-HiME Manga: "WHAT IF"s?!
The Fire Stirring Ruby wrote:What if there was ShizNat PLUS the love triangle between Yuuichi, Mai and Natsuki, would the whole story be changed?
Not really, it would just add more of conflict between Shizuru and the other girls. There's not much Shizuru can do (if she were influenced again) since she isn't a HiME in the manga. ;p
Highman wrote:but what If Shizuru like men the whole time and had fling with Yuuichi instead of Reito.
It would scary, taking Shizuru's unique personality into consideration. But hey, it's about time Shizuru became straight for once.
Re: Mai-HiME Manga: "WHAT IF"s?!
What if the "3 Greatest Young Beauties" weren't Marie Antoinette and Yang Guifei, but instead the OL would choose among the 12 HiMEs?? Of course, Mai Tokiha is given already, since it's Takumi who's the OL here.
The Fire Stirring Ruby- Ramen Noodles Specialist
- Posts : 1669
Bubuzuke points : 2486
Armitage GUTS!!! : 746
Join date : 2010-12-19
Age : 27
Location : Upstate Sass City
Re: Mai-HiME Manga: "WHAT IF"s?!
That's a tough question, Ruby. If we were to cater to his aggressive evilness, he would smart to choose Haruka as one of the Young Beauties. :) She's a loose cannon after all.
Re: Mai-HiME Manga: "WHAT IF"s?!
what if Nao wasn't a hime in the manga like fujino?
how could you work her storyline??? :/
how could you work her storyline??? :/
SpiderNeKoHiME- Spider Queen
- Posts : 1070
Bubuzuke points : 1353
Armitage GUTS!!! : 278
Join date : 2010-05-03
Age : 40
Location : Spider webz :3
Re: Mai-HiME Manga: "WHAT IF"s?!
Only thing I can think of is her getting involved in the Mai/Tate/Straight-Natsuki love triangle. *thinks about the scene with Nao on top of Tate with her shiny bare ass feeling the gentle breeze*
Yum.
Yum.
Re: Mai-HiME Manga: "WHAT IF"s?!
What if Mai became a PRINCESS, like Shiho, Alyssa and Sister Yukariko?
The Fire Stirring Ruby- Ramen Noodles Specialist
- Posts : 1669
Bubuzuke points : 2486
Armitage GUTS!!! : 746
Join date : 2010-12-19
Age : 27
Location : Upstate Sass City
Re: Mai-HiME Manga: "WHAT IF"s?!
The Fire Stirring Ruby wrote:What if the "3 Greatest Young Beauties" weren't Marie Antoinette and Yang Guifei, but instead the OL would choose among the 12 HiMEs?? Of course, Mai Tokiha is given already, since it's Takumi who's the OL here.
You can't take Mai out of the three great beauties. She's immortal now but I would replace Natsuki and Haruka.
Haruka would be awesome as the strongest out of the great.
Highman- Valkyrie
- Posts : 479
Bubuzuke points : 634
Armitage GUTS!!! : 113
Join date : 2010-09-12
Re: Mai-HiME Manga: "WHAT IF"s?!
What if Arika came out to be what she is in the fake movie trailer here? Would the manga pull more fans to read?
The Fire Stirring Ruby- Ramen Noodles Specialist
- Posts : 1669
Bubuzuke points : 2486
Armitage GUTS!!! : 746
Join date : 2010-12-19
Age : 27
Location : Upstate Sass City
Re: Mai-HiME Manga: "WHAT IF"s?!
The Fire Stirring Ruby wrote:What if Arika came out to be what she is in the fake movie trailer here? Would the manga pull more fans to read?
Only if they released it after SUNRISE's Rick Roll of a trailer (and the Mai-Otome anime series). I don't know how popular Arika is as a character, but she's enough of a draw to have Mai-fans purchase the manga and see what she's like as a villainess. Me being a major Arika fan, I'd have that issue on a plane heading towards U.S. shores as soon as it's available on Amazon Japan.
Re: Mai-HiME Manga: "WHAT IF"s?!
If Mai accepted the offer of the Obsidian, would everything in her world change? Would she have been alive though she is in a crystal while Takumi is alive???
(I'm running out of what if's here. Would anyone like to post their WHAT IF?)
(I'm running out of what if's here. Would anyone like to post their WHAT IF?)
The Fire Stirring Ruby- Ramen Noodles Specialist
- Posts : 1669
Bubuzuke points : 2486
Armitage GUTS!!! : 746
Join date : 2010-12-19
Age : 27
Location : Upstate Sass City
Re: Mai-HiME Manga: "WHAT IF"s?!
What if Searrs actually achieve this PRINCESS they had been doing? Searrs is downplayed alot in the series but it would be nice to how SEARRS could the big bad after the OL arc. Takumi being the OL could great if don't well but it was executed poorly in the manga.
GAP- Valkyrie
- Posts : 265
Bubuzuke points : 429
Armitage GUTS!!! : 126
Join date : 2010-12-26
Age : 36
Re: Mai-HiME Manga: "WHAT IF"s?!
GAP wrote:What if Searrs actually achieve this PRINCESS they had been doing? Searrs is downplayed alot in the series but it would be nice to how SEARRS could the big bad after the OL arc. Takumi being the OL could great if don't well but it was executed poorly in the manga.
If they did achieved it, probably the PRINCESSes would follow the commands of the Obsidian Lord.
The Fire Stirring Ruby- Ramen Noodles Specialist
- Posts : 1669
Bubuzuke points : 2486
Armitage GUTS!!! : 746
Join date : 2010-12-19
Age : 27
Location : Upstate Sass City
Re: Mai-HiME Manga: "WHAT IF"s?!
Well here goes nothing. What if Yuuichi had found a way to be together with both Mai and Natsuki at the same time and they both accepted it ?
hildebrant- Coral student
- Posts : 644
Bubuzuke points : 888
Armitage GUTS!!! : 233
Join date : 2011-02-09
Age : 40
Location : The sunken City of R'Lyehh
Re: Mai-HiME Manga: "WHAT IF"s?!
Then, good for Yuuichi! LOL
But seriously, I doubt that would work. Yuuichi met Mai first.
He must have already had an attraction to her.
And besides, both girls aren't always willing to share the same man.
The whole threeway affair is a weird thing in general.
But seriously, I doubt that would work. Yuuichi met Mai first.
He must have already had an attraction to her.
And besides, both girls aren't always willing to share the same man.
The whole threeway affair is a weird thing in general.
Bluholic711- Meister Otome
- Posts : 3957
Bubuzuke points : 4629
Armitage GUTS!!! : 626
Join date : 2012-03-23
Age : 33
Location : Rhode Island
Re: Mai-HiME Manga: "WHAT IF"s?!
hildebrant wrote:Well here goes nothing. What if Yuuichi had found a way to be together with both Mai and Natsuki at the same time and they both accepted it ?
Tate having a polygamous relationship (a popular subject as of late on my empire)? If he managed to pull that off, then I hope he can make Natsuki and Mai feel special at the same time without driving any kind of wedge between them. And if they accept it, that makes him one hell of a super pimp.
Re: Mai-HiME Manga: "WHAT IF"s?!
M.I.Y.U. Greer wrote:hildebrant wrote:Well here goes nothing. What if Yuuichi had found a way to be together with both Mai and Natsuki at the same time and they both accepted it ?
Tate having a polygamous relationship (a popular subject as of late on my empire)? If he managed to pull that off, then I hope he can make Natsuki and Mai feel special at the same time without driving any kind of wedge between them. And if they accept it, that makes him one hell of a super pimp.
Twice tonight I'm commenting on your responses. I realize polygamy isn't likely in the least. I just say this because I support both Yuuichi/Mai and Yuuichi/Natsuki. Dunno if He'd actually be able to get both the girls to want to share him for any length of time without a brutal fight breaking out between them. Still its why I have fanart to satisfy my urges
hildebrant- Coral student
- Posts : 644
Bubuzuke points : 888
Armitage GUTS!!! : 233
Join date : 2011-02-09
Age : 40
Location : The sunken City of R'Lyehh
Re: Mai-HiME Manga: "WHAT IF"s?!
What if Mai Tokiha became the obsidian lord rather than Takumi?
Bluholic711- Meister Otome
- Posts : 3957
Bubuzuke points : 4629
Armitage GUTS!!! : 626
Join date : 2012-03-23
Age : 33
Location : Rhode Island
Re: Mai-HiME Manga: "WHAT IF"s?!
Bluholic711 wrote:What if Mai Tokiha became the obsidian lord rather than Takumi?
Then I'd be intrigued by what roles she'd give everyone of her friends once she rose to power and predictably cured Takumi of his heart issues. Where would you go from there Mai?
hildebrant- Coral student
- Posts : 644
Bubuzuke points : 888
Armitage GUTS!!! : 233
Join date : 2011-02-09
Age : 40
Location : The sunken City of R'Lyehh
Re: Mai-HiME Manga: "WHAT IF"s?!
hildebrant wrote:Bluholic711 wrote:What if Mai Tokiha became the obsidian lord rather than Takumi?
Then I'd be intrigued by what roles she'd give everyone of her friends once she rose to power and predictably cured Takumi of his heart issues. Where would you go from there Mai?
She could always go the Jean Grey Phoenix route or maybe the "Enerjak" in Archice Sonic comics.
GAP- Valkyrie
- Posts : 265
Bubuzuke points : 429
Armitage GUTS!!! : 126
Join date : 2010-12-26
Age : 36
Re: Mai-HiME Manga: "WHAT IF"s?!
Bluholic711 wrote:What if Mai Tokiha became the obsidian lord rather than Takumi?
She'd have an epic showdown against Tate and Heterosexual Natsuki Kuga. Both are more skilled in the manga than their anime counterparts, so I see great visual potential.
Page 1 of 3 • 1, 2, 3
Similar topics
» The Mai-HiME manga vs. Mai-HiME EXA: Which had the better artwork?
» The original Mai Hime manga
» Mai-HiME Manga Collection
» Mai-HiME: Manga or Anime?
» HiME Fight Club: The Battles of Mai-HiME
» The original Mai Hime manga
» Mai-HiME Manga Collection
» Mai-HiME: Manga or Anime?
» HiME Fight Club: The Battles of Mai-HiME
Page 1 of 3
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|